Ensemble Modeling Approach to Predict the Potential Distribution of Artemisia sieberi in Desert Rangelands of Yazd Province, Central Iran
الموضوعات :Mohammad Ali Zare chahouki 1 , Peyman Karami 2 , Hossein Piri Sahragard 3
1 - University of Tehran
2 - Uinversity of Malayer
3 - Range and Watershed Department, Water and soil Faculty, University of Zabol
الکلمات المفتاحية: Soil properties, Species distribution modeling, Weighted Average AUC, Ensemble model, Iran's desert range lands,
ملخص المقالة :
The object of this study was to compare predictive accuracy of some individual modeling methods versus ensemble modeling approach in estimating the spatial potential distribution and identifying ecological requirements of Artemisia sieberi in desert rangelands of Yazd province, Central Iran. For this purpose, the species presence data were collected using the random systematic sampling method in 2019. Individual modeling of the species distribution was performed using Random Forest, Classification and Regression Tree and Generalized Additive Model after preparing environmental variable maps using GIS and geostatistics. Predictive performance of individual models was evaluated using Area Under Curve and Root Mean Square Error statistics. Furthermore, the Ensemble model was used based on the weighted average AUC. The appropriate threshold limit value was calculated based on True Skill Statistic for conversion of continuous maps to binary ones of habitat suitability. Comparison of the performance of individual models showed that the RF model had a more accurate prediction compared to the other models (AUC= 0.971 and RMSE= 0.256). Evaluation of the models implemented using threshold-dependent metrics such as Sensitivity, Specificity, and Kappa index also confirmed this finding. The overall comparison of the results from the three models versus the Ensemble model also indicates the high performance of this model compared to the individual models. Based on Ensemble model results, 45.38% of the study area had a high suitability for the establishment of A. sieberi. Based on the analysis of the importance of variables in the RF model, elevation (42%), Clay (40.02%) and pH (38.97%) in 0-30 cm soil depth had the highest effect on the presence of species. In general, Ensemble modeling can reduce the uncertainty and provide more reliable results by combining the results of the different algorithms of individual modeling.
Allouche, O., Tsoar, A. and Kadmon, R., 2006. Assessing the accuracy of species distribution models: prevalence, kappa and the true skill statistic (TSS). Journal of Applied Ecology, 43(6): 1223-1232.
Amiri, M., Tarkesh, M. and Jafari, R., 2019. Predicting the distribution of Artemisia Sieberi Besser under climate change in the steppe and semi-steppe of Iran-Touranian region. Desert Management, 7(13): 29-48.
Austin, M., 2007. Species distribution models and ecological theory: a critical assessment and some possible new approaches. Ecological Modelling, 200:1-19.
Benito Garzón, M.B., Blazek, R., Neteler, M., deDios, R.S., Ollero, H.S. and Furlanello, C., 2006. Predicting habitat suitability with machine learning models: The potential area of Pinus sylvestris L. in the Iberian Peninsula. Ecological Modelling, 197: 383-393.
Breiman, L., 2001. Random forests. Machine Learning, 45(1): 5-32.
Breiner, F.T., Guisan, A., Bergamini, A. and Nobis, M.P., 2015. Overcoming limitations of modelling rare species by using ensembles of small models. Methods in Ecology and Evolution, 6(10):1210-1218.
Capinha, C. and Anastácio, P., 2011. Assessing the environmental requirements of invaders using ensembles of distribution models. Diversity and Distributions, 17: 13-24.
Carter, G.M., Stolen, E.D. and Breininger, D.R. 2006. A rapid approach to modeling species–habitat relationships. Biological conservation, 127: 237-244.
Chen, L., Peng, S. and Yang, B.,2015. Predicting alien herb invasion with machine learning models: biogeographical and life-history traits both matter. Biological Invasions, 17: 2187-2198.
Death, G. and Fabricius, K.E. 2000. Classification and regression trees: a powerful yet simple technique for ecological data analysis. Ecology, 81: 3178-3192.
Evans, J.S. and Cushman, S.A. 2009. Gradient modeling of conifer species using random forests. Landscape Ecology, 24: 673-683.
Evans, J., Murphy, M.A., Holden, Z.A. and Cushman, S.A. 2011. Modeling species distribution and change using Random Forest. In: Drew CA, Wiersma YF, Huettmann F (eds.) predictive species and habitat modeling in Landscape Ecology. Springer New York, 139-159.
Franklin, J., 2010. Mapping species distributions: spatial inference and prediction. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Guo, C., Lek, S., Ye, S., Li, W., Liu, J. and Li, Z., 2015. Uncertainty in ensemble modelling of large-scale species distribution: effects from species characteristics and model techniques. Ecological Modelling, 306: 67-75.
Hare, K.M., Hoare, J.M. and Hitchmough, R.A., 2007. Investigating natural population dynamics of Naultinus manukanus to inform conservation management of New Zealand’s cryptic diurnal geckos. Journal of Herpetology, 41: 81-93.
Hastie, T. and Tibshirani, R., 1990. Nonparametric logistic and proportional odds regression. Journal of Applied Statistics, 260-276.
Heegaard, E. 2002. The outer border and central border for species environmental relationships estimated by non-parametric generalised additive models. Ecological Modelling, 157: 2. 131-139.
Hosseini, S.Z., Kappas, M., Zare Chahouki, M.A., Gerold, G., Erasmi, S. and Rafiei Emam, A. 2013. Modelling potential habitats for Artemisia sieberi and Artemisia aucheri in Poshtkouh area, central Iran using the maximum entropy model and geostatistics. Ecological Informatics, 18: 61-68.
Jafarian, Z. and Kargar, M., 2017. Comparison of Random Forest (RF) and Boosting Regression Tree (BRT) for prediction of dominant plant species presence in Polour Rangelands, Mazandaran Province, Iranian Journal of Applied Ecology, 6 (1): 41-55.
Kargar-Chigani, H., Javadi, S.A., Zahedi-Amiri, G., Khajeddin, S. J. and Jafari, M. 2017. Vegetation composition differentiation and species-environment relationships in the northern part of Isfahan Province, Iran. Journal of Arid Land, 9: 161-175.
Latif, Q. S., Saab, V.A., Dudley, J. G. and Hollenbeck, J.P., 2013. Ensemble modeling to predict habitat suitability for a large-scale disturbance specialist. Ecology and Evolution, 3(13): 4348-4364.
Leathwick, J., Rowe, D., Richardson, J., Elith, J. and Hastie, T., 2005. Using multivariate adaptive regression splines to predict the distributions of New Zealand’s freshwater diadromous fish. Freshwater Biology, 50: 2034-2052.
Marmion, M., Parvainien, M., Luoto, M., Heikkenen, R.K. and Thuiller, W., 2009. Evaluation of consensus methods in predictive species distribution modeling. Diversity and Distributions, 15: 59-69.
McCune, B. and Keon, D. 2002. Equations for potential annual direct incident radiation and heat load index. Journal of Vegetation Science, 13: 603-606.
Mi, C., Huettmann, F., Guo, Y., Han, X. and Wen, L., 2017. Why choose Random Forest to predict rare species distribution with few samples in large under sampled areas? Three Asian crane species models provide supporting evidence. PeerJ 5:e2849; DOI 10.7717/peerj.2849.
Mousaei Sanjerehei, M. and Rundel, P. W., 2017. The impact of climate change on habitat suitability for Artemisia sieberi and Artemisia aucheri (Asteraceae) -a Modeling Approach, Polish Journal of Ecology, 65(1): 97-109.
Pahlavan- Rad, M.R., Toomanian, N., Khormali, F., Brungard, C.W., Komaki, C.B. and Bogaert, P. 2014. Updating soil survey maps using random forest and conditioned latin hypercube sampling in the loess derived soils of northern. Iran. Geoderma, 232-234: 97-106.
Pakgohar, A. 2016. Performance comparison of Logistic Regression and Classification Regression tree models for binary dependent variable. Statistical Sciences Extension, 1(2): 7-14.
Piri Sahragard, H. and Zare Chahouki, M.A. 2015. An evaluation of predictive habitat models performance of plant species in Hoze soltan rangelands of Qom province. Ecological Modelling, 309-310: 64-71.
Piri Sahragard, H. and Zare Chahouki M.A. 2016. Comparison of logistic regression and machine learning techniques in prediction of habitat distribution of plant species. Range management and Agroforestry, 37 (1): 21-26.
Piri Sahragard, H., Keshtegar, B., Zare Chahouki, M.A. and Yaseen, Z.M. 2019. Modeling spatial distribution of plant species using autoregressive logistic regression method-based conjugate search direction. Plant Ecology, 220 (2): 267–278.
Poulos, H.M., Chernoff, B. and Fuller, P.L. 2012. Mapping the potential distribution of the invasive red shiner, Cyprinella lutrensis (Teleostei: Cyprinidae) across waterways of the conterminous United States. Aquat Invasions, 7(3): 377-385.
Ray, N. and Burgman, M.A., 2006. Subjective uncertainties in habitat suitability maps. Ecological modelling, 195(3-4), pp.172-186.
Regmi, N.R., J.R., Giardino and Vitek, J. D. 2010. Modeling susceptibility to landslides using the weight of evidence approach: Western Colorado, USA. Geomorphology, PP.1285-1293.
Sanjerehei, M.M., 2012. Soil-vegetation relationships in arid rangelands (case study: Nodushan rangelands of Yazd, Iran). World Academy of Science, Engineering and Technology, 6(7): 999-1004.
Sor, R., Park, Y.S., Boets, P., Peter, L.M., Goethals, P.L.M. and Lek, S. 2017. Effects of species prevalence on the performance of predictive models. Ecological Modelling, 354:11-19.
Stohlgren, T.J., Ma, P., Kumar, S., Rocca, M., Morisette, J.T., Jarnevich, C.S. and Benson, N. 2010. Ensemble habitat mapping of invasive plant species. Risk Analysis, 30: 224-235.
Vignoli, L., Bologna, M., Bombi, P. and Salvi, D. 2009. Modelling Bedriaga's rock lizard distribution in Sardinia: an ensemble approach. Amphibia-Reptilia, 30(3): 413-424.
Wilks, D.S., 2011. Statistical methods in the atmospheric sciences. New York: Academic press.
Zare Chahouki, M.A., Khalasi Ahvazi, L. and Azarnivand, H., 2012. Comparison of three modeling approaches for predicting plant species distribution in mountainous scrub vegetation (Semnan rangelands, Iran). Polish Journal of Ecology, 60(2): 105-117.
Zare Chahouki, M.A. and Piri Sahragard, H., 2016. Maxent modelling for distribution of plant species habitats of rangelands (Iran). Polish Journal of Ecology, 64 (4): 453-467.
