Comparing the Effectiveness of Cognitive-Behavioral Group Therapy and the Integrated Narrative Solutions Therapy on the Social Anxiety of First Grade High School Male Students

Subject Areas : Psychological Models and Methods

davood ghanbari ¹ , Abul ghasem Isa Morad ² , E. Shafeabadi ³ , noorali farokhi ⁴

1 - Ph.D. Student, Counseling Department, Faculty of Human Sciences, Islamic Azad University, Research Sciences Unit, Tehran, Iran
2 - Ph.D. in Psychology, Associate Professor, Department of Psychology, Faculty of Educational Psychology, Allameh Tabatabai University, Tehran, Iran
3 - Ph.D. in Counseling, Professor of Counseling Department, Faculty of Educational Sciences and Psychology, Allameh Tabatabai University, Tehran, Iran.
4 - Professor of Measurement and Evaluation Department, Faculty of Educational Sciences and Psychology, Allameh Tabatabai University, Tehran, Iran

Received: 2024-02-08 Accepted : 2024-05-24 Published : 2024-12-11

Keywords: cognitive behavioral therapy, integrated therapy of narrative solutions, social anxiety, students.,

Abstract :

Background and purpose: The present study was conducted with the aim of comparing the effectiveness of cognitive-behavioral therapy and integrated narrative solutions therapy on social anxiety of male students.

 

Methods: The research was applied in terms of purpose and semi-experimental in terms of implementation with pre-test-post-test and control group. The statistical population was the male students of the first grade secondary school in Lahijan city, who 45 people were selected from the registered people using the purposeful sampling method after screening and controlling the entry and exit criteria and were placed randomly in three groups of 15 people. The experimental groups underwent cognitive-behavioral group therapy and narrative solutions in 10 sessions, and the control group did not receive any training during this period. The measuring instrument of the research was the Lajersa Social Anxiety Scale for Adolescents   (SAS-A):. Finally, the data were analyzed using multivariate and univariate analysis of variance.

 

Findings: In addition to the significance of the multivariate and univariate analysis of variance test, the results of pairwise comparisons showed that the difference between the cognitive-behavioral group and the control group in total social anxiety and all its components is significant. Comparing the narrative solutions group with the control group, it was also found that the narrative solutions have a significant difference compared to the control group in total social anxiety and social avoidance and general sadness components, and there are no differences between them in the other two components. In the comparison of two experimental groups, it was also found that the cognitive-behavioral group had a more significant effect on general social anxiety and the fear of others negative evaluation than the narrative solutions group, and the differences were not significant in the other two components.

Conclusion: Both cognitive behavioral therapy and narrative solutions group can improve the social anxiety of first grade male students, and in the meantime, cognitive behavioral therapy has a greater and stronger effect, so this therapy can be used to improve students exposed to this anxiety.

References:

1) Amir N, Taboas W, Montero M. Feasibility and dissemination of a computerized home-based treatment for Generalized Anxiety Disorder: A randomized Clinical trial. Behavior Research and therapy. 2019; 120(1): 103-109. DOI: 10.1016/j.brat.2019.103446
2) Chang S, Abdin E, Shafie S, Sambasivam R, Vaingankar J A, Chong S A, Subramanian M. Prevalence and correlates of generalized anxiety disorder in Singapore: Results from the second Singapore Mental Health Study. Journal of Anxiety Disorders. 2019; 66(2): 102-108. DOI: 10.1016/j.janxdis.2019.102106
3) Ollendick, T. H., White, S. W., Richey, J., Kim-Spoon J, Ryan S M, Wieckowski A T, Smith M. Attention bias modification treatment for adolescents with social anxiety disorder. Behavior therapy. 2019; 50(1): 126-139.
DOI: 10.1016/j.beth.2018.04.002.
4) Asnaani A, Tyler J, McCann J, Brown L, & Zang Y. Anxiety sensitivity and motion regulation as mechanisms of successful CBT outcome for anxiety-related disorders in a naturalistic treatment setting. Journal of affective disorders. 2020; 93 (1): 43-21. DOI: 10.1016/j.jad.2020.01.160.
5) Haller S P, Kadosh K C, Scerif G, & Lau J Y. Social anxiety disorder in adolescence: How developmental cognitive neuroscience findings may shape understanding and interventions for psychopathology. Developmental cognitive neuroscience. 2015; 13(1): 11-20. DOI: 10.1016/j.dcn.2015.02.002
6) McAleavey A A, Castonguay L G., & Goldfried M. R. Clinical Experiences in Conducting Cognitive Behavioral Therapy for Social Phobia, Behavior Therapy. 2014; 45(1): 21-35. DOI: 10.1016/j.beth.2013.09.008 .
7) Leary M R, & Jongman-Sereno K P. Social anxiety as an early warning system: A refinement and extension of the self-presentation theory of social anxiety. In Social Anxiety. 2014; 14(2): 579-597. https://doi.org/10.1016/B978-0-12-394427-6.00020-0
8) .Leonard K, Abramovitch A. Cognitive functions in young adults with generalized anxiety disorder. European Psychiatry. 2019; 56():1-7.DOI:10.1016/j.eurpsy.2018.10.008
9) Qavami M, Fatehizadeh M, Faramarzi S, Nouri Imamzadei A. The effectiveness of narrative therapy approach on social anxiety and self-esteem of middle school girl students, School Psychology Quarterly. 2013; 3(3):62-73.
Doi: jsp-3-3-4 [Persian].
10) Turner A, Anderson L, Balderson H, Cook L, Sherman J, Cherkin, C. Mindfulness-based stress reduction and cognitive behavioral therapy for chronic low back pain: similar effects on mindfulness, catastrophizing, self-efficacy, and acceptance in a randomized controlled trail. Journal of Pain. 2016; 157(11): 2434-44.
DOI: 10.1097/j.pain.0000000000000635.
11) Clark M, Ehlers A, Hackmann A, McManus F, Fennell M, Grey N. Cognitive therapy versus exposure and applied relaxation in social phobia: a randomized controlled trial. Journal of Consulting and Clinical Psychology. 2006; 74(2): 568– 578. DOI: 10.1037/0022-006X.74.3.568
12) Fatehizadeh M, Shafiabadi A, & Etamadi A, Delawar A. Effectiveness of two methods of confrontational behavior therapy and cognitive-behavioral therapy in reducing the symptoms of female clients with borderline personality disorder in Isfahan city. Psychological Studies. 2006;2(4-3):3-24. https://www.sid.ir/paper/67609/fa[inPersian]. [Persian]
13) Beidel C, Turner S M, Young J. Social Effectiveness Therapy for Children: Five Years later. Behavior Therapy. 2006; 37: 416 – 425. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.beth.2006.06.002
14) Atari Fard M, Shayiri M, Rasulzadeh Tabatabaei K, Zorgi M, Azadfalah P, Banopour A. Investigating the effectiveness of cognitive behavioral therapy based on Hoffman's model in reducing the symptoms of social anxiety disorder. Allameh Tabatabaei University Culture, Therapy and Psychotherapy Quarterly. 2013; 3(9):51-23. https://doi.org/10.22054/qccpc.2012.6062 [Persian].
15) Hofmann S G. Avances in the reaserch of Social Anxiety and its disorder anxiety. Anxiety, stress, & coping. 2010; 23(3): 239-242. doi: 10.1080/10615801003612014
16) Qadri Z, Khodadadi Z, & Abbasi Z. Effectiveness of integrated group therapy with the method of re-decision and narrative therapy on emotion control in adolescent girls of Shiraz city. Women and Society Quarterly. 2008; 1(3): 137-149. https://doi.org/10.1207/s15374424jccp1701_11 [Persian]
17) Naziri Q, Kadri Z, & Zare F. Effectiveness of therapeutic narrative approach in reducing depression of women in Maroodasht city. Women and society quarterly. 2009; 1 (2): 65-78.https://jzvj.marvdasht.iau.ir/browse?_action=issue[Persian].
18) Ghamari kivi H, & mojarad A. comparison of the Effectiveness of Narrative-focused and Solution-focused Questioning on Anxiety Reduction in People with Over Anxiety Disorder. Journal of Preventive Counselling. 2020;1(2):1-12. https://jpc.uma.ac.ir/article_968_fa2dadf7def6b1c1309dd2e679feefbf.pdf [Persian]
19) La Greca A. The social anxiety scales for children and adolescents. The Behavior Therapist. 1999; 22(7): 133- 136. https://psycnet.apa.org/record/2001-16694-002
20) La Greca A, Dandes K, Wick P., Shaw K, & Stone W. Development of the Social Anxiety Scale for children: Re liability and concurrent Validity. Journal of Clinical Child Psychology. 1988; 17(1): 84- 91. https://doi.org/10.1207/s15374424jccp1701_11
21) Khawaja L, & Hosseinchari M. Investigating the relationship between social anxiety and psycho-social classroom atmosphere with academic self-efficacy in middle school students. Educational Psychology (Psychology and Educational Sciences. 2011; 7(20): 131-153. https://doi.org/10.22054/jep.2011.6037
22) Astwar S, & Razavieh A. Examining the psychometric properties of the social anxiety scale for teenagers for use in Iran. The fifth national conference on mental health of children and adolescents, Zanjan University of Medical Sciences and Health Services. 2013;3(12):69-78. https://www.sid.ir/paper/227545/fa. [inPersian].
23) Eron, J. B., & Lund, T. W. (1996). Narrative Solutions: An Integration of Self and Systems Perspectives in Motivating Change. Journal of Psychotherapy Integration. 2007; 17(1):70-92. DOI:10.1037/1053-0479.17.1.70
24) .Artzaei B, & Noami A. The effect of cognitive behavioral therapy group, with the mediation of social problem solving, on the depression of high school girls. Social Psychology.2018;7(52):77-87. 20.1001.1.23455098.1398.7.52.8.8[Persian]
25) Annie J. Relations of age with changes in self-efficacy and physical self-concept in preadolescents participating in a physical activity intervention during afterschool care. Perceptual and Motor Skills. 2007; 105(1), 221-226. DOI: 10.2466/pms.105.1.221-226
26) Rector A, Laposa M, Kitchen K, Bourdeau D, & Joseph-Massiah L. Anxiety disorders: An information guide. camh, Centre for Addiction and Mental Health. 2016;. https://www.camh.ca/-/media/files/guides-and-publications/anxiety-disorders-information-guide2016.pdf
27) Melkam M, Segon T, Nakie G. Social phobia of Ethiopian students: meta-analysis and systematic review. Systematic Reviews. 2023; 12(41):1-10. DOI: 10.1186/s13643-023-02208-2
28) Noda SH, Shirotsuki K, & Nakao M. Low-intensity mindfulness and cognitive–behavioral therapy for social anxiety: a pilot randomized controlled trial. 2024; 24(190):1-16. https://bmcpsychiatry.biomedcentral.com/articles/10.1186/s12888-024-05651-0
29) Dixon M L, Moodie C A, Goldin P R., Farb, N., Heimberg RG, & Gross J J. Anxiety disorder: Reappraisal and acceptance of negative self-belifes. Biological Psychiatry: Cognitive Neuroscience and Neuroimaging. 2020; 5(1): 119-129. DOI: 10.1016/j.bpsc.2019.07.009