Empowering Economic Development: Integrating Economic-related Issues into Secondary School Curricula
Amir Toghyani
1
(Department of Educational Sciences, Islamic Azad University, Isfahan (Khorasgan) Branch, Isfahan, Iran)
Jahanbakhsh Rahmani
2
(Department of Educational Sciences, Islamic Azad University, Isfahan (Khorasgan) Branch, Isfahan, Iran)
Narges keshtiaray
3
(Department of Educational Sciences, Islamic Azad University, Isfahan (Khorasgan) Branch, Isfahan, Iran)
کلید واژه: Economic Development, Curriculum, Secondary School, education, G7 Countries,
چکیده مقاله :
In today’s rapidly evolving global economy, it is essential to equip young learners with the necessary skills and knowledge to thrive in the workforce and contribute to economic development. Education is the vital driver of human capital and development in countries, and the success of any educational system depends heavily on its curriculum. This paper aims to study the pivotal role of the curriculum in shaping education and its contribution to economic development. In particular, this paper studies four components (objectives, content, teaching-learning methods, and evaluation) of secondary schools’ curricula in G7 countries (Italy, France, Japan, US, Canada, Germany, UK) and Iran to present a set of proposed concepts for the Iranian curriculum with a focus on economic features. George Brady's comparative strategy (description, interpretation, juxtaposition, comparison) was used in this qualitative research. The proposed concepts are arranged in three layers: the first includes improvement of A) scientific skills (mathematics and basic sciences), B) technical skills (general profession and technological literacy), and C) process skills (systemic thinking and problem-solving). The study of world history and geography as well as other countries’ languages and cultures is the second part. The third includes altruism for others, the environment, and the future. This study serves as an introduction to the skills and abilities needed by Iranian students to compete in the real world. The proposed curriculum model offers a clear summary of some of the essential competencies for tomorrow’s society and workplace.
چکیده انگلیسی :
Empowering Economic Development: Integrating Economic-related Issues …
Empowering Economic Development: Integrating Economic-related Issues into Secondary School Curricula
Received Date: Accepted Date:
Abstract
In today’s rapidly evolving global economy, it is essential to equip young learners with the necessary skills and knowledge to thrive in the workforce and contribute to economic development. Education is the vital driver of human capital and development in countries, and the success of any educational system depends heavily on its curriculum. This paper aims to study the pivotal role of the curriculum in shaping education and its contribution to economic development. In particular, this paper studies four components (objectives, content, teaching-learning methods, and evaluation) of secondary schools’ curricula in G7 countries (Italy, France, Japan, US, Canada, Germany, UK) and Iran to present a set of proposed concepts for the Iranian curriculum with a focus on economic features. George Brady's comparative strategy (description, interpretation, juxtaposition, comparison) was used in this qualitative research. The proposed concepts are arranged in three layers: the first includes improvement of A) scientific skills (mathematics and basic sciences), B) technical skills (general profession and technological literacy), and C) process skills (systemic thinking and problem-solving). The study of world history and geography as well as other countries’ languages and cultures is the second part. The third includes altruism for others, the environment, and the future. This study serves as an introduction to the skills and abilities needed by Iranian students to compete in the real world. The proposed curriculum model offers a clear summary of some of the essential competencies for tomorrow’s society and workplace.
Key Words: Education, Curriculum, G7 Countries, Secondary School, Economic Development
Introduction
As a driver of nations and a crucial element of countries’ human capital, education has the ability to improve the skill sets of students and helps the economy benefit from skilled and qualified workers (WEF, 2016). According to the World Economic Forum (2016), education improves a country’s economy as follows: 1) it improves the skill set of people to handle existing and future tasks and careers, 2) it transfers the new and required knowledge to juvenile students, especially secondary school (Barro & Lee, 2010), and 3) it should lead each country to create unique knowledge, technologies, etc.
The core of each educational system is its curriculum (Priestley & Philippou, 2019) and is a powerful lever for preparing and improving students’ performance to have a successful future (OECD, 2020). As the curriculum embraces the overall learning experiences both inside and outside of the school, the curriculum of each society must adapt to the needs of that society (Kranthi, 2017). The term curriculum can be considered the result of the intersection of schools, government, and society (Wahlström, 2022). Some research has proven that the curriculum is conceptually challenging, and there is no single definition or general agreement about it (OECD, 2020). Although every country has its curriculum and approach for its students, almost all educators agree on objectives, content, methods, and evaluation as key elements of the curriculum (Toghyani Khorasgani et al., 2023). On the other hand, if the educational system of a country cannot equip students with sufficient skills and qualifications, even if that country has many natural resources (such as Iran), its economy will not grow (Haseeb et al., 2021).
The economic recession due to the COVID-19 pandemic adds urgency to the task which is accompanied by more unemployment and a rise in the need for workers with more advanced ability. However, while the majority of scholars stress the decrease of school failure as a goal, Iran showed little consistency in its policies and procedures to help low-performing disadvantaged schools and students. No changes have occurred to the curriculum except for conducting school in a virtual format instead of in person. As a result, there are still difficulties in determining the optimum sorts of policies and procedures to apply (Mahmoudi, 2023; Khojasteh et al., 2021; Mirarab et al., 2019).
A rich body of research shows that human capital and investment in education lead to a country’s economic development (UNESCO, 2012; Woessmann, 2016; Hanushek et al., 2017; Bradley & Green, 2020). The knowledge of economic issues is accepted as one of the skills needed in daily life, and in this regard, educational institutions in some countries plan their educational programs in a way that, in addition to teaching basic and necessary skills such as reading and writing literacy, economic development for the future of those countries is achieved after the students finish their education (Klapper et al., 2015). According to IIASA (2008), most economically developed countries see secondary education as playing a major role in economic growth. Although there is a wealth of evidence showing the link between education and economic growth, there is little research on curriculum elements as a powerful lever to economically improve the future of a nation.
The purpose of the present study is to examine four elements (objectives, content, teaching-learning methods, and evaluation) of the formal curriculum in secondary schools in the Islamic Republic of Iran and 7 countries (Italy, France, Germany, Japan, Canada, UK, and the United States) with a particular focus on economic features to propose concepts required for inclusion in the Iranian national high school curriculum based on economic development. The research questions focused on “How G7 countries dealt with the economic features and market needs in their secondary schools’ curricula?” and “What new concepts should be included in the Iranian national secondary school curriculum to enable its students to compete in international markets?”.
Methodology
This research embraces a qualitative approach. According to Aspers & Corte (2019), qualitative research aims to consider a fact in its natural environment, which leads to profound knowledge about the studied fact. This study examined and compared the four elements (objectives, content, teaching-learning methods, evaluation) of the curriculum in G7 countries and Iran, particularly focusing on economic features, to propose needed concepts for the Iranian national secondary school curriculum. George Brady's comparative strategy (description, interpretation, juxtaposition, & comparison) was used in this qualitative research.
The three criteria for choosing G7 countries for this study were primarily their gross national product (GDP). According to World Bank data (2022), all 7 countries are among the top 10 countries by GDP ranking.
USA | UK | Japan | Italy | Germany | France | Canada | Iran |
25.46 Trillion | 3.07 Trillion | 4.23 Trillion | 2.01 Trillion | 4.07 Trillion | 2.78 Trillion | 2.14 Trillion | 388.54 Billion |
Table 1- Countries by GDP in 2022
GDP (current US$), year 2022. Data source: https://data.worldbank.org/indicator
Appendix 1 explains the procedure for obtaining these data from worldbank.org.
Secondly, access to the sources and documents of these countries (appendix 2 shows the list of web addresses to access resources). Finally, the unemployment levels in these countries with intermediate education are shown in Table 2. According to the International Standard Classification of Education 2011 (ISCED 2011), intermediate education contains upper secondary and non-higher education.
Table 2 - Unemployment with intermediate education (% of total labor force with intermediate education)
USA | UK | Japan | Italy | Germany | France | Canada | Iran |
7% | 4% | 5% | 9% | 3% | 8% | 10% | 10% |
Notes: % of total labor force with intermediate education, 2021 (except UK, 2019). Data source: (World Development Indicators). Appendix 3 explains the procedure for obtaining these data from https://data.worldbank.org/indicator
Four elements of objectives, content, teaching-learning methods, and evaluation were collected from the sources. Using the well-known George Brady method, a descriptive comparative analysis was carried out. Four stages of description, interpretation, juxtaposition, and comparison are used to identify the economic-oriented elements in the studied countries. In the next step, after extracting economic-related components of the curriculum in G7 countries and Iran, these elements were put into a questionnaire and sent to a group of experts (5 men and 8 women) to calculate the agreement coefficient (Table 3). The Delphi model is utilized to collect the opinions of experts and gain consensus. The Delphi model was run for 2 rounds to gain consensus.
Table 3- Results of calculations of Kendall's coefficient of agreement for double rounds of Delphi
No. | Kendall’s Correlation Coefficient | Sig. level |
13 | 0.909 | 0.001 |
Then, the proposed concepts were sent to some professors, postgraduate students of curriculum planning, and secondary school teachers (400 participants) to confirm their feasibility. All the collected responses (321) were positive and proved that the proposed concepts are related to economic development and can be taught in secondary school classrooms.
After extracting the required information from the sources, the obtained information was categorized and analyzed based on the George Brady model. In the first stage, Description, the elements of objectives, content, teaching-learning methods, and evaluation were studied for all G7 countries with a focus on economic features. In the second stage, interpretation, the studied elements of the curriculum G7 countries were checked and interpreted. In the third stage, juxtaposition, the data related to the studied elements of the curriculum for each country came together so that similarities and differences could be easily compared in the next stage. Final stage, comparison: Based on the data of the previous stage, data juxtaposition, the similarities and differences of objectives, content, teaching-learning methods, and evaluation of the curricula in the G7 countries were identified (Table 4) to propose needed concepts for Iran.
Table 4- The similarities and differences of objectives, content, teaching-learning methods, and evaluation in the secondary schools of G7 countries (focusing on economic development)
Similarities in objectives | Differences in objectives |
Developing individual, physical, intellectual, and emotional abilities; Economic growth and development; Attention to human values and virtues; Strengthen self-confidence; Flourishing creativity and talents; Developing occupational skills and readiness to enter the labor market; Acquiring knowledge and social skills; Attention to freedom, cultural diversity; | Readiness to enter university; Set tasks and strengthen taking responsibility; Respect the work; |
Similarities in content | Differences in content |
History, Mathematics, Art, economy and geography; Hygiene and health; Familiarity with computers, information and communication technology; Occupation empowerment, job-related Learning; Second or more foreign languages; Religion and morality; Education on environmental and resource protection. | Handicraft; Local beliefs; Technical studies; Chemistry and physics; Internship in business or medical professions; Organized and accumulated knowledge, terms and information; Focused textbook, subject-oriented and in the form of separate courses. |
Similarities in teaching-learning methods | Differences in teaching-learning methods |
working groups (teamwork) and cooperation between students; Encouraging participation and involvement in classroom tasks; Family cooperation and involvement with school programs; Providing collaborative techniques, training and familiarization with the work environment practically; Offering extracurricular practical activities; Providing an internship in an institution or company; improving basic work and life skills; Using the information and communication technologies and its tools | Education through the fun and games of students in schools; holding the same training courses during compulsory service for all teachers; Creating opportunities in sync with each student's interests to promote learning motivation. |
Similarities in evaluation | Differences in evaluation |
descriptive evaluation system, continuous evaluation, regular control and evaluation of educational activities by teachers and consultants, participation in academic aptitude tests and participation in national and international standard tests | Evaluation of individual discipline, evaluation of perseverance, patience, patience and internal discipline of the student, mainly descriptive exams, existence of long exams to enter commercial or medical fields. |
The four elements of the curriculum in secondary school according to its “Fundamental Reform Document of Education” are shown in Table 5.
Table 5- Elements (objectives, content, methods, evaluation) of Iran's secondary curriculum
Curriculum’s elements | Explanation of elements |
Objective | Flourishing human nature, realistic and appropriate to the ability and time and place conditions; realization of a pure and pleasant personal and social life (Hayat Tayyaba); student's reasoning-centered educational course; Strengthening human virtues; Setting tasks according to the correct standards of communication; God-centered; Integrated intellectual, religious, practical and moral training of students; Understanding and ability to continuously improve personal and social situation |
Content | Accumulated knowledge, terms, information, facts, laws, principles, methods, concepts, generalizations, phenomena, problems related to each lesson; Collection of concepts; A coherent set of opportunities, basic learning experiences and competencies based on values and creating the background for the flourishing of the divine nature (in the form of Connected and centered on the relationship with God); Similar textbook and subject-oriented for all secondary students; Emphasis on necessary knowledge to enter the university; Titles of content: Islamic wisdom and knowledge, Quran and Arabic, Persian language and literature, culture and art, health and physical education, work and technology, humanities and social studies, mathematics, experimental sciences, foreign languages, life skills and family foundation; |
Method | 37 weeks of training and exams from the first of October to the end of June; The average weekly working hours of secondary school in Iran is 50 hours; The time allocated to each session and the rest time between them is a total of 60 minutes, and the combination of two lessons is not allowed; The second secondary course has three branches: theoretical, technical, professional and associate; Counseling and educational guidance is mandatory in all academic courses; Intelligent use of new educational technologies and using them with a strengthening and complementary view; interaction of students with teachers, peers and earning environments; Understand and interpret phenomena, events, and relationships in real situations; Understanding and making decisions about the issues that students face in different situations by observing the Islamic standard system; Creating opportunities to acquire needed competencies; creating opportunity to link opinion and action, combine previous knowledge and experiences with new learning materials. |
Evaluation | The basis for selection, passing academic courses and permission to higher grades for students; maintaining the human dignity of students; Designing and implementing a result-oriented evaluation system; Grading system and GPA with a maximum score of 20; based on national curriculum to provide descriptive and judgmental information with quantitative and qualitative results; Continuous monitoring (diagnostic, formative and final) |
Discussion
One of the primary tasks of any educational system in a country is to educate efficient students with the necessary skills to enter the labor market after finishing school (Haskel & Jenkins, 2009). Since the curriculum is regarded as the foundation of every educational system (Priestley & Philippou, 2019), curriculum elements are key levers for making students ready for the present and future needs of society. Studying the curriculum of other countries and benefiting from their related experiences and knowledge can help curriculum planners and educational policymakers make correct decisions and choose the right path. In the present study, the curriculum elements of 7 countries with high GDP were examined to understand how they dealt with the economic features and market needs in their secondary schools’ curricula. The reviewed literature showed that there is not much emphasis on economic features and market needs in the elements of the curriculum in the Iranian secondary education system as it is not an economically developed country (Mahmoudi, 2023; Khojasteh et al., 2021; Mirarab et al., 2019).
In this research, new concepts that needed to be considered to add to the current concepts in the Iranian national secondary school curriculum to enable Iranian students to compete in international markets were identified in three layers (Fig. 1).
Figure 1- Proposed concepts for the Iranian secondary curriculum with a particular focus on economic development
Layer 3. Paying attention to moral virtues (altruism), health, and the environment, and looking ahead to the effects of these things on human societies | ||
Layer 2. Getting to know more about the history and geography of the world as well as the culture and language of other nations | ||
Layer 1. Improving the level of scientific, technical, and process skills | Scientific skills | Sciences |
Applied mathematics | ||
Technical skills | Technology literacy | |
General profession | ||
Process skills | Problem-solving | |
Systematic thinking | ||
The first layer includes improving the level of three categories of essential skills, including scientific skills (applied mathematics and science), technical skills (general profession and technology literacy), and process skills (systematic thinking and problem-solving). The second layer includes getting to know the history and geography of the world as well as the language and culture of other countries. The third level includes paying attention to moral virtues (altruism of fellow humans), health, environment, and looking ahead to the effects of these things on human societies. These three layers are explained in detail below.
Layer 1. Improving the level of scientific, technical, and process skills
A. Scientific skills: Applied mathematics and sciences
Almost all Iranian students complain about the lack of relevance of course subjects to the real world and the abstract nature of school subjects. Many topics seem abstract and cannot be applied or transferred to the workplace and society (Zinser & Poledink, 2005). It is the teachers’ art to make the connections explicitly or to arrange topics in a way for the students to discover the connections and usefulness. Students should be able to answer this question: "Why should I learn this?". When students connect what they are learning to their potential occupations of interest, their drive to study improves. Ideally, courses should be taught in applied or practical settings, which emphasize connections between topics and real-world experience.
As a learning strategy, the REACT model contains five components, relating, experiencing, applying, cooperating, and transferring, to help students relate math and science materials to everyday life and solve problems in real-world life (Crawford, 2001). This model begins with "relationship" or linking the new concepts with new real-life contexts, experiences, or problems. The next component is "experience", which means students' understanding and achievement through discovery and solving real problems. "Applying" is the third step, and this strategy enhances students' understanding through relevant meaningful activities that engage students in learning. This following is then "Cooperation," or learning by sharing, communicating, and working with others. Finally, "transferring" is the use of skills in a new situation or context that was not studied in class (Khatimah & Fatmah, 2021). The REACT strategy leads students to acquire skills needed to enter the real-world context and competitive market by learning to explore their knowledge and skills, defining the learning process as lifelong learning, improving communication skills, and solving new emergent problems (Musyadad & Avip, 2020). Therefore, for mathematics and sciences, a more effective learning approach, such as the REACT strategy, should be used in Iranian secondary schools.
B. Technical skills
General vocational skills include preparation for a profession, job or at least one career path (OECD, 2011). At the secondary school level, the goal is to provide students with the necessary skills and knowledge for a successful transition to both the market and university. Approximately two-thirds of jobs in the market require some form of secondary education, and almost all careers demand ongoing learning. Most American high schools offer students work-based learning opportunities for those who may seek employment directly after secondary school (OECD, 2011; Kis, 2011).
Future awareness indicates that many of the vocations and professions that today's students will pursue have not yet been created, as the current ones did not exist a decade ago. Therefore, the notion of preparing for a broad professional path—rather than a single career—may be the greatest method of educating today's students (Mann et al., 2020).
Therefore, instead of looking for a specific job that may be changed or eliminated by global developments (e.g., the banking industry, with the emergence of new technologies and cryptocurrencies), young people should gain a broad understanding of career paths and the labor market (Akkermans et al., 2021; Cole et al., 2014).
It is preferable for many pupils to achieve some early success before continuing. The concept of career paths equipped students with the necessary professional skills and qualifications for postsecondary school, whether they choose to continue their education at higher levels or directly enter market labor. Regardless of the selected option (some students may modify their choice later), students learn valuable skills that are transferable to a new position and prime them to move forward in any occupation (Van Rooij et al., 2017).
The rapid development of knowledge and the dominant role of technology in accelerating its development is guaranteed. According to Churchill (2020), it is essential to develop digital literacy in the 21st century. In a study, A Nation at Risk, the US recognized the need for technology literacy, particularly computer technology, to be included in the secondary school curriculum (A Nation Risk, 1983, p.26). Technology literacy is a concept that includes grasping the fundamental principles (design and functioning) behind various technologies, as well as comprehending their effects on both society and the environment. The positive impact of technology on the economy is broadly acknowledged. In 2009, the United Nations Educational, Scientific and Cultural Organization highlighted the importance of technology skills for entering the labor market. Moreover, the US in the “Partnership for 21st Century Skills” recognized technology skills as pivotal skills for effective participation in society and the workforce (Partnership for 21st Century Skills, 2010).
In an ever-advancing technological landscape, there is a concern that only a handful of individuals will grasp the intricate workings of complex systems, leaving the majority with the mere ability to switch devices on and off. The underlying argument is that everyone should possess the skills to effectively “use, manage, evaluate and understand technology” (ITEA, 2002, p. 1). In today's fast-paced technological world, students are taught a valuable lesson that the newest technology may not always be the most suitable option. They grasp the significance of selecting appropriate technology based on specific situations, rather than simply opting for what is trendy or popular.
Iranian educators should answer the call for technology skills by creating national standards as well as developing a curriculum in a way that technology literacy is included in secondary education. As technical skills are crucial for effective participation in the competitive labor market, the full range of technology competencies should be included in national educational standards.
C. Process skills
Systems thinking is essential in poorer countries that use education as a key factor in reducing poverty reduction. Systems thinking helps students feel comfortable with paradoxes and uncertainty. This leads students to see the whole, holistic approach instead of the parts and patterns of isolated events. Unlike linear or mechanistic cause-and-effect systems, complex systems can involve many internal and external variables and interactions and often have temporally and spatially delayed consequences, hence it may be difficult to understand the connections. To facilitate adjustments and improvements, systems thinking employs a set of guidelines and instruments (Hynes et al., 2020).
Senge (1990) identified common patterns called "systemic archetypes" to help train people in systems thinking. For example, learning to detect delays in a system, when the impact of one variable on another variable is not immediately observed, helps to avoid rapid reaction while waiting for the desired outcome. Another example is caution about short-term solutions, which may have some benefits but can simply delay the inevitable problem because the root cause of the system is not addressed. While short-term solutions may seem appealing and effective in addressing immediate issues within a particular system, it is important to consider their potential unintended negative consequences. These consequences can arise either in another part of the system or even at a later time. Therefore, it is crucial to carefully evaluate the long-term impact of any solution before implementing it, ensuring holistic and sustainable outcomes for the entire system.
Students may not naturally grasp this way of thinking, which is why it is crucial to introduce it through a variety of engaging methods such as problem-solving, real-life events, and case studies. To understand a system, students can create a diagram of its components and interactions. The diagram may look like an iceberg, for example, starting with the visible part of actual events (the small part) and reaching the lower parts as hidden conditions and behaviors (the large part). A more complex system may require causal loops in two or three stages to detect its patterns. By incorporating case studies into their learning process, students can analyze systems to identify the root causes of problems and then propose various solutions to improve the system. Young individuals have the incredible ability to constantly question established theories, delve into assumptions, and scrutinize generalizations that are often made about specific countries or cultures
Problem-solving skills are a subset of systems thinking but can be applied more broadly. Problem-solving should be a regular and orderly process that usually follows a step-by-step procedure such as analysis, design, development, implementation, and evaluation. Students quickly learn that there are often many possible solutions to a problem, each with different benefits, costs, impacts, etc., so students learn to use appropriate strategies to find solutions to the problems (Dwivedi & Srivastava, 2021). This process also develops related skills such as communication (listening, negotiation) and teamwork skills (valuing different perspectives). According to Rossman (1993), by using problem-solving skills, students should learn how to face challenges and have an active role in dealing with problems or events.
Computer simulations have recently been used as a tool to solve the problem, possibly increasing its complexity. Simulated problems allow students to change the pace of action, isolate or eliminate variables, and reverse decisions—all in a safe environment so that the effects of each variable can be studied. In educational settings, we can include nonfinal answers or need for improvement as opposed to the fixed "answers" at the end of the book. In fact, the learning process is more important than solving specific problems, which leads to competence and a sense of comfort in facing problems or events that at first seem unsolvable or challenging (Ferreira & Trudel, 2012; Ezeddine et al., 2023).
Process skills are useful for almost every job and profession. A course in "critical thinking" immerses students in systems thinking and problem solving and can be implemented in secondary school. Therefore, the curriculum should be planned in a way that supports students in acquiring systems thinking and problem-solving skills and applying them in real-life situations.
Layer 2. Getting to know more about the history and geography of the world as well as the language and culture of other countries
A. World history and geography
Studies of world history and geography embrace knowledge of the world and historical timelines, comprehending civilizations, and global migration. Ideally, this course would also include political dynasties and wars and the history of art and science. The current generation grew up in school with computers and digital media, not realizing that these technologies are relatively new inventions. On a bigger scale, the three living generations have experienced industry and automation, not realizing that historically these are relatively recent phenomena and that humankind has survived for thousands of years without them. Studying geography and history can help to understand the evolution of civilizations. These subjects need to be covered in secondary school courses. The teacher is aware of many cultures and enjoys teaching globally (Ontario Ministry of Education, 2004; Scott-Rilton, 2015).
Past events have displaced families and groups of people and changed the regions. Such events have also created new systems of government that have endured for generations after their inception. All these affect every person alive today. For example, the great economic recessions in the world, which left many people worldwide unemployed and countless families homeless, caused governments to learn how to help and support their citizens. This effort led to the creation of a variety of insurance systems to cover almost all residents, as well as government support programs in times of emergency.
History is based on a list of chronological events. When studying the changes in a culture or country, one learns what key events contributed to this and why they were so important. Therefore, they understand what is important to a culture and country and what actions are needed to bring about change. These changes can include a wide range, from changing the attitude of the business environment to continuing to compete in a specific field to larger changes such as changing values and distrust of citizens toward the policies of a government (Harari, 2022).
The challenges around the world including those related to energy, food security, migration, poverty, urban planning, climate change, and natural disasters, are increasing (Favier & van der Schee, 2014). These challenges exist at different range of sizes from local to global, are divided between natural and human systems, and include a number of interrelated factors that are dynamically changing. Although difficult to comprehend, forecast, and overcome, these challenges are crucial to our future.
One of the primary aims of teaching geography in secondary schools is to provide students with the skills necessary to address the difficulties they see or read about in a more comprehensive knowledge (Committee on Economic Development, 2006). Students must learn to reason about and make judgments about solutions to these challenges so that they are capable of making wise decisions in their daily lives and future careers. A growing number of educators around the world are convinced that the ability to think about these issues is the key to developing these competencies, and teaching geography can help develop spatial thinking (Kerski, 2008; Lee & Bednarz, 2009).
Spatial thinking refers to the knowledge, skills, and mental habits related to the use of spatial concepts. Spatial representation tools and spatial reasoning processes (Bednarz & van der Schee, 2006). The authors of the well-known book “Learning to Think Spatially” claim that spatial thinking is a form of global thinking that is helpful in a range of academic areas and real-world problem-solving scenarios (Bednarz & van der Schee, 2006). Huynh and Sharpe (2012) argued that spatial thinking is the core of the theoretical and practical underpinnings of geography.
B. Language and culture
Learning the language and culture of another country, ideally from a different continent, is another important aspect of the curriculum (Sadr et al., 2022; MD Jahangiralam and Akter, 2021). Students learn that every culture has challenges, that there is more than one way to overcome any challenges, and that there is no universal consensus (silver bullet) on how to face similar challenges. Studying about another nation enables students to transcend egocentric and ethnocentric viewpoints. This prepares students to "compete" in global markets. In secondary school, students must show "global literacy" (Committee on Economic Development, 2006, p. 26), which means proficiency in at least a foreign language and knowledge of global issues, such as history, geography, economic development, cultures and poverty.
Schools may have to provide teachers with professional development opportunities to add an international perspective to all the subjects they teach. Teachers should include the topic of internationalization in their preparation programs (Roberts, 2007). Governments can integrate international content into secondary schools’ curricula. Schools can also use innovative technologies like immersion programs and simulations so that students can connect with other nations. Leaders in politics, business, education, and the media must emphasize the importance of global literacy (Committee on Economic Development, 2006). Business leaders and educators in Iran should do their best to identify the required knowledge and skills to actively participate in the global market and business, as well as step up their efforts to help curriculum improvement and promote student exchange, arts and culture.
In general, the study of geography and history assists students in becoming responsible and contributing members of today’s complex society, which is marked by sophisticated and fast economic, technological, social, and political change.
Layer 3. Paying attention to moral virtues (altruism), health, and the environment and looking ahead to the effects of these things on human societies
A. Moral Virtues and Human Values (altruism)
One of the few cross-cultural notions is altruism. This concept is commonly interpreted to mean an interest in others’ welfare and is frequently taught to students through service-learning initiatives in their communities. In addition, altruism for the planet (Earth altruism) means positive attention to all communities, species, and ecosystems (Österblom & Paasche, 2021). Third, people should feel responsibility and sacrifice toward future generations, which will definitely be affected by current decisions. It is an extension of the Golden Rule, which states that people should treat others as they would like to be treated (morality and human virtue), a version of which appears in many religions and philosophies (Neusner & Chilton, 2008). This does not imply that, in order to receive good treatment, one must also give good treatment to others (a conditional statement). Instead, it implies that how people treat others, which is altruistic, is a reflection of how they desire to be treated.
Although there may not be consensus on the teaching of values and ethics in all districts and schools, altruism has the potential to go beyond debates about what should be taught. Students need to be socialized by teachers and adult role-playing. secondary school students develop the cognitive ability to understand others’ points of view.
Students should have the chance in the classroom to interact with one another, offer assistance to one another, discuss and write about the actions and moral quandaries of fictional characters, and recognize their own and others' feelings. According to researchers, it is possible to develop values by showing how positive behavior improves relationships and solves group problems (Robinson & Curry, 2005). Higher education usually focuses on extrinsic values, such as career development, rather than building students’ personalities, but secondary school curricula can provide a combination of both (Birnik & Billsberry, 2007).
Altruism for the Earth is a concept that becomes very important when we realize that - on a global scale - all people use the same air and water. Earth is the origin and the main common source among all humans. It should not be exploited by the people of a country or ethnic group for short-term gain (for which all humans pay the long-term cost). Therefore, students at this level of education should be ecologically literate, which is "understanding the principles of organization, common to all living systems, that ecosystems have evolved to sustain the web of life" (Capra, 2002, p. 230).
The term "interdependence" refers to the relationship between the welfare of one species and the welfare of all species. The needs of the group are more important than the needs of the individual, yet the individual develops as the group thrives (MacPherson, 2005). From this perspective, all living beings have an equal right to live on earth and survive. Economic values are often the default basis of international negotiations and should, along with altruism (global ethics), become a common ground for communication and a criterion for decision-making.
B. Health and environment
Human health occupies a key position on Maslow hierarchy of human needs. One of the most important international documents in the field of health that includes children up to the age of 18 is the United Nations Convention on the Rights of the Child (UNCROC). To date, 193 countries have joined this international document, and the Islamic Republic of Iran is also a member of this international convention. In this convention, several articles clearly mention the right to health for children and the role of educational institutions. According to Narin and Smith (2003), health is a term in which different organizations are involved and different dimensions are hidden in it. Different dimensions of health include physical, mental, and environmental health. The fact that schools can play a major role in health promotion has been recognized by the World Health Organization (WHO, 1997) under the title of Health-Promoting School Initiatives (HPS) (Nader, 2000). Schools' health promotion initiatives focus on a comprehensive idea of health and wellness in the context of everyday life in the community rather than providing services to the sick and those in need of care (Raeburn & Rootman, 1988). Generally, citizens of countries with stronger economies are in much better condition in terms of physical, emotional, spiritual, and mental health than those of countries with weak economies. Economically leading countries include health and hygiene topics in the content of their curriculum from elementary school and emphasize it (Smith et al., 2004).
Clearly, with the physical and cognitive growth of students, these materials can be updated with more detailed information. Mental and emotional health causes students to have better and healthier social relationships with each other at school and with family, which eventually leads to the growth of these relationships in the larger local communities and ultimately the global community (Booth & Samdal, 1997). The healthier people in society are in terms of physical and mental health, the more government costs to support the sick will be reduced, and as a result, a healthier living environment for citizens will lead to economic growth. (Ridhwan et al., 2022).
The oldest definition of environmental education is that of William Stapp, a professor at Michigan University, in 1969 (Fang et al., 2022). He defined environmental education:
“as a process producing a citizenry that is knowledgeable concerning the biophysical environment and its associated problems, aware of how to help solve these problems, and motivated to work toward their solution” (Stapp et al. 1969, p. 30)
Today, the teaching of environmental literacy may be done through interdisciplinary studies such as economic development (Environment Kuznets Curve- “EKC”) with the topic of ecology. For example, in secondary school, students can study the waste stream to understand that waste is not "thrown out" but rather "in a landfill, in the ocean, in the forest, on the planet." They should know the economic value of waste segregation and learn about fertilizer production. Investigating the relationship between increasing environmental quality and economic growth will be useful for policymakers to design and implement effective policies such as changes in educational policies to achieve sustainability goals. (Singh & Yadav, 2021).
Conclusion
One of the main responsibilities of the school is to prepare students for fast social, economic and environmental changes, future jobs, technologies and problems (Akkermans et al., 2021; Mann et al., 2020, Cole et al., 2014; Kis, 2011; Shobeiri et al., 2007). Education aims to address the present and future needs of society along with individual growth. Previous studies have emphasized that the educational goals of each country have a professional and economic aspect in addition to the social aspect. Education is an important factor in economic development and improving living standards (Howells, 2018).
Secondary schools are essential for preparing students for the economic challenges of the future. By implementing an economic-oriented curriculum, schools can contribute significantly to economic development. Investigating the secondary school curricula of 7 countries with high GDP and the national secondary school curriculum of Iran in this research shows that the G7 curricula are more economically oriented, which has led to better preparation and performance of students for the labor market.
If Iran wants to prepare its secondary school students for the current and future society and markets, it should redesign its curriculum with the help of relevant stakeholders to bridge the skills gap, foster an entrepreneurial mindset, encourage partnerships between schools and local industries, and integrate focused subjects needed for economic development. Iranian secondary schools should provide opportunities for students to connect their learning to the real world. This requires collaborative and interdisciplinary learning as well as mastery of discipline knowledge.
It is important to note that while these 7 studied countries have successfully implemented an economically oriented curriculum in secondary schools, each system has unique characteristics and may not be directly replicable in any context. However, studying these examples can provide valuable insights and inspiration for countries seeking to enhance their own curriculum. Therefore, the predetermined national curriculum of Iran's secondary schools should be changed to an adaptive curriculum and be effectively aligned with evolving social and economic requirements (Toghyani Khorasgani et al., 2023)
Overall, this research proves the findings of previous studies related to countries’ curricula, such as Iran, that the curriculum is ideologically oriented and does not pay enough attention to economics, environment, and foreign language (Saparudin & Salim, 2023; Mahmoudi, 2023; Toghyani Khorasgani et al., 2023; Gholaminejad & Raeisi-Vanani, 2021; Khojasteh et al., 2021; Mirarab et al., 2019, Shobeiri et al., 2007).
Despite its novelty, the current research suffers from some shortcomings that must be acknowledged. It should be acknowledged that some of the studied countries, such as Germany, the UK, the USA, and Canada, have multiple curricula for secondary schools (the UK has four separate curricula; Germany has 16 federal states and 4 different types of schools with a curriculum unique to each), but Iran has only one national curriculum for its secondary schools, even in different regions.
References
Akkermans, J., Collings, D. G., Da Motta Veiga, S. P., Post, C., & Seibert, S. E. (2021). Toward a broader understanding of career shocks: Exploring interdisciplinary connections with research on job search, human resource management, entrepreneurship, and diversity. Journal of Vocational Behavior, 126, 103563. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jvb.2021.103563
Aspers, P., & Corte, U. (2019). What is Qualitative in Qualitative Research. Qualitative Sociology, 42(2), 139–160. https://doi.org/10.1007/s11133-019-9413-7
Atwool, N. (1999) New Zealand children in the 1990s: beneficiaries of New Right economic policy? Children and Society, 13, 380-393.
Barro, R. J. and J.-W. Lee. (2010) “A New Dataset of Educational Attainment in the World, 1950–2010.” NBER Working Paper No. 15902. Cambridge, MA: National Bureau of Economic Research.
Bednarz, S. W., & Van Der Schee, J. (2006). Europe and the United States: the implementation of geographic information systems in secondary education in two contexts. Technology, Pedagogy and Education, 15(2), 191–205. https://doi.org/10.1080/14759390600769573
Birnik, A., & Billsberry, J. (2007). Reorienting the business school agenda: the case for relevance, rigor, and righteousness. Journal of Business Ethics, 82(4), 985–999. https://doi.org/10.1007/s10551-007-9607-x
Booth, M.L. and Samdal, O. (1997). Health promoting schools in Australia: models and measurement. Australian and New Zealand Journal of Public Health, 21, 365-371.
Bradley, S. & Green, C. (Eds.) (2020). The economics of education: A comprehensive overview (2nd ed.). Elsevier. https://doi.org/10.1016/C2017-0-02304-2
Capra, F. (2002), The Hidden Connections: Integrating the Biological, Cognitive, and Social Dimensions of Life into a Science of Sustainability, Doubleday, New York, NY.
Churchill, N. (2020). Development of students’ digital literacy skills through digital storytelling with mobile devices. Educational Media International, 57(3), 271–284. https://doi.org/10.1080/09523987.2020.1833680
Cole, S., Paulson, A., & Shastry, G. (2014). Smart money? The effect of education on financial outcomes. Review of Financial Studies 27(7), 2022–2051. https://doi.org/10.1093/rfs/hhu012
Crawford, M. (2001), ‘‘Teaching contextually: research, rationale, and techniques for improving student motivation and achievement in mathematics and science’’, Center for Occupational Research and Development. http://eslmisd.pbworks.com/w/file/fetch/67547032/Teaching%20Contextually%20to%20motivate%20students.pdf
Dwivedi, R., & Srivastava, S. (2021). Developing Problem Solving Skill in Secondary Students. Horizons of Holistic Education, 8(1). https://www.researchgate.net/publication/355167462_Developing_Problem_Solving_Skill_in_Secondary_Students
Committee for Economic Development (2006), Education for Global Leadership: The Importance of International Studies and Foreign Language Education for US Economic and National Security, Committee for Economic Development, Washington, DC. https://www.ced.org/pdf/Education-for-Global-Leadership.pdf
Ezeddine, G., Souissi, N., Masmoudi, L., Trabelsi, K., Puce, L., Clark, C. C. T., Bragazzi, N. L., & Mrayah, M. (2023). The problem-solving method: Efficacy for learning and motivation in the field of physical education. Frontiers in Psychology, 13. https://doi.org/10.3389/fpsyg.2022.1041252
Fang, W., Hassan, A., & LePage, B. A. (2022). Introduction to Environmental Education. The Living Environmental Education, 3–24. https://doi.org/10.1007/978-981-19-4234-1_1
Favier, T., & Van Der Schee, J. (2014). The effects of geography lessons with geospatial technologies on the development of high school students’ relational thinking. Computers & Education, 76, 225–236. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.compedu.2014.04.004
Ferreira, M. M., & Trudel, A. R. (2012). The Impact of Problem Based Learning (PBL) on Student Attitudes toward Science, Problem-Solving Skills, and Sense of Community in the Classroom. The Journal of Classroom Interaction, 47(1), 23–30. https://dialnet.unirioja.es/servlet/articulo?codigo=3923111
Gholaminejad, R. & Raeisi-Vanani, A. (2021). English language teaching in Iranian mainstream schools: Pedagogical, societal and government policy environments. Issues in Educational Research, 31(1), 111-129. http://www.iier.org.au/iier31/gholaminejad.pdf
Hanushek, E. A., Schwerdt, G., Wiederhold, S. & Woessmann, L. (2017). Coping with change: International differences in the returns to skills. Economics Letters, 153, 15-19. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.econlet.2017.01.007
Harari, Y. N. (2022, October 18). To change our future, we should change how we teach history to children. The Guardian. https://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2022/oct/18/change-future-teach-history-children
Haskel, J., & Jenkins, S. J. (2009). Teaching Economic Principles through Literacy Methods, Idaho State University, Journal of Economics and Economic Education Research, 4(2): 19-43.
Haseeb, M., Kot, S., Hussain, H. I. & Kamarudin, F. (2021). The natural resources curse economic growth hypotheses: Quantile–on–quantile evidence from top Asian economies. Journal of Cleaner Production, 279, article 123596.
Howells, K. (2018). The future of education and skills: Education 2030: The Furue We Want. OECD. https://repository.canterbury.ac.uk/item/88qzy/the-future-of-education-and-skills-education-2030-the-future-we-want
Huynh, N. T., & Sharpe, B. (2012). An Assessment Instrument to Measure Geospatial Thinking Expertise. The Journal of Geography, 112(1), 3–17. https://doi.org/10.1080/00221341.2012.682227
Hynes, W., M. Lees and J. Müller (eds.) (2020), Systemic Thinking for Policy Making: The Potential of Systems Analysis for Addressing Global Policy Challenges in the 21st Century, New Approaches to Economic Challenges, OECD Publishing, Paris, https://doi.org/10.1787/879c4f7a-en
IIASA. (2008, August). Economic Growth in Developing Countries: Education Proves Key (Policy Brief #03). International Institute for Applied Systems Analysis. https://iiasa.ac.at/web/home/resources/publications/IIASAPolicyBriefs/pb03-web.pdf
Kerski, J. J. (2008). The role of GIS in Digital Earth education. International Journal of Digital Earth, 1(4), 326–346. https://doi.org/10.1080/17538940802420879
Khatimah, H., & Fatmah. (2021). REACT Strategy Aided by Cabri 3D to Improve Students’ Mathematical Connection Ability. Advances in Engineering Research, 209, 229–234. https://doi.org/10.2991/aer.k.211215.043
Khojasteh, F., Osareh, A., Hajiani, E., & Araghieh, A. (2021). Investigating the challenges of national identity in Iran’s Seccondary school curriculum. Quarterly Journal of Management and Leadership Studies in Educational Organizations, 1(2), 29–51. https://mlseojournal.ctb.iau.ir/article_683723.html?lang=en [in Persian]
Kis, V. (2011). Learning for Jobs OECD Reviews of Vocational Education and Training: United States: Texas. OECD. http://search.oecd.org/education/skills-beyond-school/47150751.pdf
Klapper, L. F., Lusardi, A. & Panos, G. A. (2015). Financial Literacy and the Financial Crisis, World Bank Policy Research, Working Paper, No. 5980: 18-29
Kranthi, K. (2017). Curriculum development. IOSR Journal of Humanities and Social Science, 22(2), 1-5. https://doi.org/10.9790/0837-2202030105
Lee, J., & Bednarz, R. S. (2009). Effect of GIS Learning on Spatial Thinking. Journal of Geography in Higher Education, 33(2), 183–198. https://doi.org/10.1080/03098260802276714
MacPherson, S. (2005), ‘‘Educating ecological citizens of The Blue Planet’’, Canadian Journal of Environmental Education, Vol. 10 No. 1, pp. 141-56.
Mann, A., Denis, V., Schleicher, A., Ekhtiari, H., Forsyth, T., Liu, E., & Chambers, N. (2020). Dream Jobs: Teenagers’ Career Aspirations and the Future of Work. OECD. https://www.oecd.org/berlin/publikationen/Dream-Jobs.pdf
Mahmoudi, S. (2023). Studying the status of parameters of economic education in the humanities curriculum at high schools. Journal of Development Strategy, 4(72), 1402021342106. http://rahbord-mag.ir/en/Article/42106 [in Persian]
Md. Jahangir Alam, & Aktar, T. . (2021). Comparative Curriculum Critique and Analysis of Secondary School English Language Teaching. International Journal of English Language Studies, 3(6), 12–21. https://doi.org/10.32996/ijels.2021.3.6.2
Mirarab, R., Hajitabar, M., & Arianfar, S. (2019). Analysis of Economic Literacy Components of Secondary School Textbooks from the Viewpoint of Teachers and Students. Journal of Educational Planning Studies, 7(14), 121–132. https://eps.journals.umz.ac.ir/article_2128.html [in Persian]
Musyadad, M. A., & Avip, B. (2020). Application of react (relating, experiencing, applying, cooperating, transferring) strategy to improve mathematical communication ability of junior high school students. Journal of Physics. https://doi.org/10.1088/1742-6596/1521/3/032048
Nader, P.R. (2000). Health promoting schools: why not in the United States? Journal of School Health, 70, 247-252.
National Commission on Excellence in Education. (1983). A Nation at Risk. Washington, DC. Retrieved from http://datacenter.spps.org/sites/2259653e-ffb3-45ba-8fd6-04a024ecf7a4/uploads/SOTW_A_Nation_at_Risk_1983.pdf
Neusner, J., & Chilton, B. (2008). The golden rule: The ethics of reciprocity in world religions. https://doi.org/10.5040/9781472549440
OECD. (2011). OECD Reviews of Vocational Education and Training: Learning for Jobs. OECD. https://study.com/learn/lesson/vocational-skills-overview-examples.html
OECD. (2020). Curriculum (re)design: A series of thematic reports from the OECD Education 2030 project. https://www.oecd.org/education/2030-project/contact/brochure-thematic-reports-on-curriculum-redesign.pdf
Ontario Ministry of Education. (2004). The Ontario curriculum: Social Studies, grades 1 to 6, History and Geography, grades 7 and 8. Ontario Ministry of Education. https://www.uwindsor.ca/education/sites/uwindsor.ca.education/files/curriculum_-_social_studies_1-6_history_geography_7-8.pdf
Österblom, H., & Paasche, Ø. (2021). Earth altruism. One Earth, 4(10), 1386–1397. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.oneear.2021.09.003
Partnership for 21st Learning. (2010). Up to the challenge: The role of career and technical education and 21st century skills in college and career readiness. https://files.eric.ed.gov/fulltext/ED519335.pdf
Priestley, M. & Philippou, S. (2019). Curriculum is – or should be – at the heart of educational practice. The Curriculum Journal, 30(1), 1-7. https://doi.org/10.1080/09585176.2019.1598611
Raeburn, R. and Rootman, I. (1998) People-centered Health Promotion. Wiley, Toronto
Ridhwan, M. M., Nijkamp, P., Ismail, A., & MIrsyad, L. (2022). The effect of health on economic growth: a meta-regression analysis. Empirical Economics, 63(6), 3211–3251. https://doi.org/10.1007/s00181-022-02226-4
Roberts, A. (2007), ‘‘Global dimensions for schooling: implications for internationalizing teacher education’’, Teacher Education Quarterly, Vol. 34 No. 1, pp. 9-26. https://www.teqjournal.org/backvols/2007/34_1/07roberts.pdf
Robinson, E. H., & Curry, J. R. (2005). Promoting altruism in the classroom. Childhood Education, 82(2), 68–73. https://doi.org/10.1080/00094056.2006.10521349
Rossman, A. B. (1993). Making connections: Organization development and total quality management process. Organization Development Journal, 11(1), 51–56.
Sadr, A., Kian, M., Sadeghi, A., & Abbasi, E. (2022). A Comparative Study of Secondary School Art & Culture Curriculum in Australia, Canada, Malaysia and Iran. Iranian Journal of Comparative Education, 5(4), 2183–2209. https://doi.org/10.22034/IJCE.2021.257295.1247
Saparudin & Salim, A. (2023). The rise of Islamic movements and dilemmas for contemporary Islamic education: A study in Lombok, Indonesia. Issues in Educational Research, 33(2), 733-751. http://www.iier.org.au/iier33/saparudin.pdf
Scott-Railton, T. (2015). History and Geography in the Classroom Constructing Knowledge through Savoir-Faire (V. Barbier, Trans.). Annales. Histoire, Sciences SocialesAnnales., 70(1), 151–159. https://www.cairn-int.info/article-E_ANNA_701_0151--history-and-geography-in-the-classroom.htm
Senge, P. (1990), The Fifth Discipline: The Art and Practice of the Learning Organization, Currency Doubleday, New York, NY.
Shobeiri, S. M., Omidvar, B., & Prahallada, N. N. (2007). A comparative study of environmental awareness among secondary school students in Iran and India. International Journal of Environmental Reservation, 1(1), 28-34.
Singh, S., & Yadav, A. (2021). Interconnecting the environment with economic development of a nation. In Elsevier eBooks (pp. 35–60). https://doi.org/10.1016/b978-0-12-822188-4.00003-8
Smith, A., Gaffney, M., & Nairn, K. (2004). Health rights in secondary schools: student and staff perspectives. Health Education Research, 19(1), 85–97. https://doi.org/10.1093/her/cyg007
Stapp WB (1969) The concept of environmental education. Environ Educ 1(1):30–31
Toghyani Khorasgani, A., Rahmani, J. & Keshtiaray, N. (2023). Curriculum and economic development: A comparative study of secondary education in Iran and G7 countries. Issues in Educational Research, 33(1), 390-413. http://www.iier.org.au/iier33/toghyani-khorasgani.pdf
UNESCO Institute for Statistics (2012). International standard classification of education. UNESCO Institute for Statistics.
Van Rooij, E., Jansen, E., & Van De Grift, W. (2017). First-year university students’ academic success: the importance of academic adjustment. European Journal of Psychology of Education, 33(4), 749–767. https://doi.org/10.1007/s10212-017-0347-8
Wahlström, N. (2022). Curriculum policy, teaching, and knowledge orientations. Teachers and Teaching, 1–17. https://doi.org/10.1080/13540602.2022.2159364
Woessmann, L. (2016). The economic case for education. Education Economics, 24(1), 3-32. https://doi.org/10.1080/09645292.2015.1059801
WHO (1997) Promoting Health through Schools. Report of a WHO Expert Committee on Comprehensive School Health Education and Promotion. Technical Report Series 870. WHO, Geneva
World Economic Forum (2015). Global Competitiveness Report 2015-2016. http://reports.weforum.org/global-competitiveness-report-2015-2016/education/#view/fn-53
Zinser, R. and Poledink, P. (2005), ‘‘The Ford Partnership for Advanced Studies: a new case for curriculum integration in technology education’’, Journal of Technology Education, Vol. 17 No. 1, available at: http://scholar.lib.vt.edu/ejournals/JTE/v17n1/zinser.html
Appendix 1
Procedure for obtaining data (Table 1) from worldbank.org
https://data.worldbank.org/indicator/NY.GDP.MKTP.CD?locations=CA-FR-DE-IR-US-GB-JP-IT
Appendix 2
List of web addresses to access resources
Appendix 3
Procedure for obtaining these data (Table 2) from: https://data.worldbank.org/indicator
https://data.worldbank.org/indicator/SL.UEM.INTM.ZS?locations=IR-US-GB-FR-IT-JP-DE-CA
